Diamond guide

Can a Diamond Tester Be Wrong?

Watch on YouTube

Yes, both ways. A basic tester can read moissanite as diamond, and some diamonds can read as moissanite. A tester's light is a clue, not a verdict: to know for certain, ask a gemologist or a lab. Watch the one-minute video to see why.

How a diamond tester works

A basic thermal tester reads how fast a stone moves heat, and moissanite can pass it: in a 1997 study, every moissanite on every thermal tester read as diamond. Testers added a second check, electricity, on the rule that moissanite conducts and diamond doesn't.

Why it can be wrong, both ways

  • Moissanite that doesn't conduct: in a 1997 study, 10 of the 23 moissanites tested showed no conductivity.
  • Diamonds that do conduct: a trace of boron makes a diamond conduct, and many HPHT lab-grown diamonds contain boron. Not all of them would fool a tester, and nobody publishes how often it happens.
  • The tester makers say so too: one maker now warns that some lab-grown diamonds test as moissanite, and some moissanite tests as diamond.

To know for certain, ask a gemologist or a lab. For more about lab-grown diamonds, watch How Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Made? and What Is Moissanite?, or read Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Real? 10 Myths Debunked.

Video transcript

A basic tester reads how fast a stone moves heat. In a 1997 study co-written by GIA staff and a director of the company selling moissanite, every moissanite on every thermal tester read as diamond. So testers added a second check, electricity. The rule was simple: moissanite conducts, diamond doesn't.

Except in that same study, 10 of the 23 moissanites showed no conductivity. And some diamonds do conduct. A trace of boron does it, and more than four in five of the HPHT lab-grown diamonds sent to GIA since 2020 contain boron. Not all of those would fool a tester, and nobody publishes how often it happens.

But one tester maker, which also sells a newer tester, now warns that some lab-grown diamonds test as moissanite, and some moissanite tests as diamond. So a tester's light is a clue, not a verdict. To know for certain, ask a gemologist or a lab.

This video is AI-generated: the pictures are AI-made illustrations and the narration is an AI voice.

Sources

  • Nassau et al., Gems & Gemology, Winter 1997 (lead author a director of the company selling moissanite)
  • Eaton-Magaña et al., Gems & Gemology, Summer 2024
  • A tester maker's own guidance (Presidium)